Frequently Asked Questions: how do eye doctors determine the prescription when a child can’t talk or read an eye chart

One of the questions that you run in to a lot when you have a very little one in glasses is how an eye doctor can determine the prescription of kids who can’t read letters yet — and in many cases, aren’t verbal yet.  It was one of the things I wondered about when we took Zoe in at 9 months old.  It turns out that eye doctors (optometrists and ophthalmologists) have a number of tools to help them do this.  At Zoe’s early appointments, they used Teller Cards (grey cards with black and white lines on them) as well as dilating her eyes and using the retinoscope to look at the shape of her eye.  The Teller cards are an example of a subjective measurement of her acuity – it requires some response from her, in this case, it was whether or not she looked at the black and white squares.  Other examples of subjective measurements include eye charts, which can use letters or symbols.  The retinoscopy was an objective refraction.  That is, it looked at the shape of her eye to see how well she could focus without requiring a response from her.

Teller Acuity Cards, from www.stereooptical.com

Teller Acuity Cards, from http://www.stereooptical.com

For a more complete explanation of how it all works, I turned to Dr. Dominick Maino, OD, MEd, FAAO, FCOVD-A.  He is a Professor of Pediatrics/Binocular Vision at the Illinois Eye Institute/IllinoisCollege of Optometry and is in private practice in Chicago, Il.  He also writes about latest research in vision and vision care of children at MainosMemos.

An objective examination of refractive error (myopia, also known as nearsightedness or shortsightedness; hyperopia, also known as farsightedness or longsightedness; and astigmatism) can be completed several ways.  You can use an auto-refractor (though most do not work well for little ones) where the child looks at this computerized device and it tells you the refractive error. Eye doctors can also use a retinoscope. This is a small handheld flashlight that directs a light into the eye.  When it is reflected back out, depending upon the type of refractive error, it will move in a certain way. We then neutralize this movement by placing lenses in front of the eye. Once we see no movement, we know the refractive error. In terms of accuracy, they are all accurate depending upon several factors.

Retinoscopy.  From National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health Ref#: EE95

Retinoscopy. From National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health Ref#: EE95

The same pretty much applies to the subjective measurement of visual acuity. Teller Cards, Snellen Chart and the Lea Symbols all measure visual acuity but slightly differently. Once again all are accurate. I am not quite as concerned about the number generated by the visual acuity test at this age.  I am much more concerned with both eyes having similar numbers. You want both eyes to see equally as well. [emphasis mine – Ann Z]

Now on to prescribing for little ones: Giving glasses is still as much art as it is science (something about humans being so…well human!). For example, most people want to be fully corrected if they have myopia (nearsightedness / shortsightedneess) so they can see clearly at all distances.  Hyperopia (farsightedness / longsightedness) is even more tricky. If you are farsighted and a child, you can compensate for the farsightedness by kicking in your focusing ability. Unfortunately this can lead to major problems such as accommodative esotropia: when you compensate for the high amount of hyperopia by using your focusing system, an eye turn inwards results (from MainosMemos, “What is Accomodative Esotropia?“). To complicate matters even more, ophthalmologists and optometrists have different philosophies when it comes to prescribing glasses. Ophthalmologists tend to prescribe for higher amounts of farsightedness, while Optometrists lower. The good news is that for infants and toddlers we probably prescribe in a similar way.

The important thing is to find a doctor you trust and follow his/her advice. Don’t be afraid to seek out a second opinion and don’t be surprised if that second opinion if different from what you’ve been hearing.  Ask lots of questions. Ask why the doctor is recommending what they are recommending. If the doc doesn’t have the time to fully explain what he/she is doing, find a new doc.  I hope this helps!!!”

— Ann here again.  Many, many thanks again to Dr. Maino for the explanations.  

A reader found this video a while ago that does a nice job of illustrating how the retinoscopy described above works.

Advertisements

3 responses to “Frequently Asked Questions: how do eye doctors determine the prescription when a child can’t talk or read an eye chart

  1. So I have found out today that my 4yo needs glasses after getting a second opinion, these last few weeks have been terrible for me as I can’t understand how I missed it, my boy can kick a ball do puzzles and almost wright his own name. The first optometrist we visited used drops to dilate and said he was a +10 longsighted and has been like this all his life, prescription of +7 or +8 to start. We felt so bad about this I insisted on a second look this time no drops as we told the second optometrist the result from last week, and this time confirmed possible +10 but only looking to prescribe a +4 to start off……this seems to be a big difference and I’m unsure what to do next.

    Like

    • Hi Stanley, first, please don’t feel bad about missing this, as you said, your son has shown no signs of vision issues. That’s normal, for what it’s worth, catching vision issues, particularly farsightedness, can be very difficult in young children. It is very common to start a farsighted child with a lower prescription. This is in part because it’s easier for the child to adjust to, and because most young children are hyperopic at that age (though usually more around +1). Did either of the optometrists give a reason for their starting prescription? Or did you find one or the other as having a better working style for your son? If you’re still unsure, you might ask each about why they are recommending the prescription they are, and what they see as the treatment plan going forward, and what their goals are for your son’s vision. Best of luck!

      Like

  2. Wow, I had no idea these are the types of techniques eye doctors use for children who are too young to speak. It’s really helpful to know that doctors have these techniques because we really want to take our 11 month old baby in and get her eyes checked. Some people might say that is too early, but we want to make sure she doesn’t start off her life with already prevalent health problems.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s